top of page
  • Writer's pictureRobert Schuerger II

Demystifying the Complexities: What Is Personal Injury Fraud?

In recent times, the topic of personal injury fraud has taken center stage in many discussions. However, what is personal injury fraud? Well, it's the act of making deceptive personal injury claims to obtain unjust compensation from an insurance company.

Such false injury claims can vary from exaggerated wounds to entirely fabricated accidents. Hence, the insurance industry often has to distinguish between genuine and fraudulent personal injury claims.

This deception can affect insurance coverage and bring legal consequences for those found committing personal injury fraud. Moreover, this article dives deep into this issue, explaining the various types of fraud and their implications. Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys can also explain things like what is a release in a settlement.

What Is Personal Injury Fraud?

What Is Personal Injury Fraud?

Personal injury fraud is a deceptive act where an individual intentionally misrepresents information about an injury or accident to obtain insurance coverage or greater compensation than they are entitled to.

Think of it as a scenario where someone claims they had a severe slip and fall accident, but it never happened or wasn't as bad as stated. Insurance companies often find themselves challenged by fraudulent personal injury claims, whose main goal is exploiting the system.

Whether through an inflated claim or completely made-up incidents, the intent is clear: to benefit from deceit. These actions not only strain the resources of insurance companies but also bring about serious ramifications for the culprits, ranging from civil penalties to criminal charges.

It's a shady side of the personal injury world that every individual and insurance company should be aware of.

Types of Fraudulent Personal Injury Claims

Fraudulent claims in personal injury cases refer to attempts made to deceive insurance companies. Such deceptive practices come in various forms, primarily categorized into soft and hard insurance fraud.

Soft Insurance Fraud

Soft insurance fraud, a more common deceptive practice, generally involves exaggerating real injuries. An individual might have an actual injury, perhaps from a minor accident, but blows it out of proportion when making the insurance claim. They do this to maximize the compensation amount.

Someone with an old back injury, for example, might attribute increased pain to a recent, unrelated incident, thus inflating the claim. While the injuries are real, the misrepresentation seeks to take undue advantage of the insurance company's compensation mechanisms.

Hard Insurance Fraud

On the other hand, hard insurance fraud is a more severe and deliberate transgression. This process includes either staging an accident or intentionally causing harm to oneself or another, aiming to file a fraudulent personal injury claim.

Imagine a scenario where two vehicles intentionally collide with each other, only to claim accident-covered compensation later. Such acts are premeditated, with the clear intent of deceiving the insurance company.

Beyond just the financial implications for insurance providers, these schemes can have criminal consequences for those committing fake injury claims.

Fraud is an act intended to wrongfully gain a settlement, leading to severe ramifications when discovered. Furthermore, this highlights the importance of the best personal injury attorneys in Nashville for both victims and insurance firms to ensure justice prevails.

Consequences of Personal Injury Claim Fraud

When someone makes a fraudulent personal injury claim, they might think they're simply trying to get more compensation. However, the repercussions of such actions can be hefty, affecting both the individual and the insurance company.

Let's dive into the potential consequences of personal injury insurance fraud:

  • Financial impacts: Insurance companies often raise premiums for everyone when they deal with frequent false personal injury claims. This means higher costs for all policyholders, not just the fraudster.

  • Civil penalties: If an insurance company suspects a fraudulent claim, they might refuse to pay. Additionally, the firm can sue the person to recover an already paid compensation. In such cases, the individual could end up owing the company a lot of money instead.

  • Criminal charges: Insurance fraud, whether it's soft or hard, is a crime in many jurisdictions. People found guilty can face jail time, fines, or both.

  • Record impact: Being found guilty of a fraudulent claim can lead to a criminal record. This record can affect future employment opportunities and even personal relationships.

  • Loss of insurance: Insurers can deny the insurance claim and decide not to renew the person's policy. Finding new insurance coverage might then become difficult and expensive.

  • Legal consequences: If someone is caught committing fraud, they may need to defend themselves in court. This process would require hiring a personal injury lawyer, leading to more expenses.

While getting a bigger settlement might seem tempting, the risks associated with a fraudulent personal injury claim far outweigh the potential benefits. It's always best to be honest and upfront when dealing with insurance claims.

Impact on the Insurance Company

Insurance companies are critical in providing financial safety nets for many people. However, when a fraudulent claim, especially one related to personal injury insurance fraud, comes into the picture, it disrupts this system.

Such deceitful actions don't just affect the individual making the personal injury claim. They also have broader consequences. Hence, the insurance company may increase premiums for everyone, even those who've never made a claim.

This can happen because the company must balance out its losses from insurance hoaxes, including hard and soft insurance fraud types. An insurance company might even face civil and criminal penalties in extreme cases, leading to a significant financial setback.

Essentially, dishonest claims can destabilize the foundation of trust and can come with high costs for both individuals and insurers.

The Crucial Role of Legal Representation in a Fraudulent Personal Injury Claim

The Crucial Role of Legal Representation in a Fraudulent Personal Injury Claim

In insurance claims, especially those revolving around personal injuries, having someone on one's side who knows the ropes is vital. An experienced lawyer becomes indispensable in these situations. They can help differentiate an actual personal injury insurance claim from a fake one, ensuring justice is served.

The expert team at Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys has stood out in this domain, taking a firm stance against fraudulent claims and ensuring that actual victims see the justice they deserve. With this team, compensation isn't just about money but about righting wrongs and restoring faith in the system. They can also explain the difference between bodily injury vs personal injury.


Personal injury fraud isn't a small matter but a serious issue that affects many people and entities. Making a fraudulent claim undermines genuine victims and strains the entire insurance system.

In this challenging landscape, the Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys team shines brightly. The firm is deeply committed to ensuring that honest individuals receive the compensation they deserve.

It tirelessly works to separate real personal injury insurance claims from false ones, ensuring that justice prevails. Moreover, the firm's dedication safeguards individuals and restores trust in the process.


bottom of page